Tuesday, August 29, 2006

Dilemma

The Choice

The intellect of man is forced to choose
perfection of the life, or of the work,
And if it take the second must refuse
A heavenly mansion, raging in the dark.
When all that story's finished, what's the news?
In luck or out the toil has left its mark:
That old perplexity an empty purse,
Or the day's vanity, the night's remorse.

~ William Butler Yeats

Yours truly is in a quandary. Should I take a safe and stable job at MHA or should I take a risk and accept a job offer that is of sales component with HSBC? Both jobs are obviously good additions to my resume, but each has pros & cons. For MHA, being a civil service career, yours truly can expect bureaucratic red tape and slow promotion, especially because I am of the wrong gender. But it does offer a reasonable pay with bonus and a good start in a new job function that I have not tried. Of course, another benefit is that there is no bond, so if I dislike the job, I have the option of jumping ship.

For HSBC, it is obviously a great organisation to add to my CV. It is an extremely difficult organisation to get into (yours truly had to do both a verbal and maths test, and than a 3 hrs long test centre), it offers the opportunity to learn about investment (which is of personal benefit and helps my MBA application) and it is a sales job, so it is conceivably the only job that I might be able to earn enough to go do my MBA in the US in 3 yrs time. The cons are the facts that it is a sales job with sales targets to meet and yours truly is bonded for a year.

What's a girl gotta do?

Different people are offering me different advice.

*Sheer's supportive parents argue very convincingly against HSBC and for MHA. Being parents, they would prefer yours truly to take a civil service "iron rice bowl" job and of course, not bond myself down again. *Sheer's dad also mentioned that yours truly is not up to the pressure of sales. He said that yours truly won't be a cut above the rest in a sales job and MHA is a very good addition to my CV. Again, yours truly have to concede that he might have a point.

*Eccentric says that both are not perfect jobs for me, but she concedes that I have a point when I say that HSBC is a good break into the financial market and helps when I apply for MBA. But again, it's back to - DO I WANNA DO SALES? The answer is, ambivalent.

Maybe in light of the ambivalence, yours truly should turn down the job. Because its a full 12 months. So I shldn't start the slate on ambivalence?

*Wallflower says just to wait for a more ideal job to come along. But yours truly is keen to start working. Other than being broke, I'm also getting bored. So I am actually quite ready to start work.

*Peaceful and *Candid both says it is really up to me but *Peaceful says she would personally take MHA for the stability and *Candid says she would personally not take a sales job. Again, they are not exactly helpful, but comments appreciated nonetheless.

*007 who is in banking gave the most direct and perhaps useful advice (bascially cos yours truly assumed that since he is in banking, he would know best) - he said that HSBC is an okay organisation but if the position is personal wealth banker, I won't like it, and it can be pretty stressful. And that, seems to say it all.

So here I am. With barely one day left to make my decision (for HSBC anyway). As of this moment, yours truly is more inclined to take everyone's argument against HSBC. Afterall, dad is a great sales person and he comes into contact with bankers. So if he says I won't be outstanding in the job, I have to give him the benefit of the doubt. Yes?

In a perfect world, one can work at the perfect job.

Oh well.

C'est la vie.

Sheer


4 comments:

Su Phing said...

why didn't ask me!!?!

=)

Me gut feel says ministry. I don't like banks. really.

Yours truly said...

Yours truly didn't wanna bother too many people over what essentially should be me and my decision. plus, you seemed busy lately. :)

And yours truly didn't even realise you still check my blog regularly. *grin*

You will be glad to know yours truly did indeed turn down the bank.

Anonymous said...

so you're going with MHA?

when are you starting work?

Yours truly said...

MHA has offered and requires 2 weeks to process the paperwork. I haven't officially accepted, but probably mid-sept if I accept, and baring unforeseen circumstances, I would probably wanna try MHA out.